Methodology · version 1

How we research and rank companies

The directory is a comparison tool, not a certification program. Every enriched fact should retain its source, observation date and level of evidence; missing data is labeled rather than converted into a negative claim.

What a company profile contains

The base catalog contains 599 public business listings. Name, address, city, website, rating, review count, hours and map link come from Google Business Profile snapshots collected September 18, 2026. A listed rating is third-party data, not a review collected by this site.

An initial 40-company pilot and a 56-company P1/long-tail expansion add official-site observations collected November 16, 2026. 68 companies currently have linked service offers; “specific services not yet checked” on other profiles means exactly that.

Evidence is not one green badge

  • Public listing: a field observed in an external business listing.
  • Company claim: a statement on the company’s own website, such as financing or a warranty.
  • Document observed: a dated document was reviewed; this is not the same as issuer confirmation.
  • Registry matched: an exact company-to-record relationship was reviewed in an official registry.
  • Issuer confirmed: the responsible issuer or agent confirmed the specific fact.

We do not use a blanket “verified” label. 36 exact eCorp matches are published; registration is shown separately from licensing and insurance.

Identity and geography stay separate

A brand, legal entity, branch and shared franchise domain are not automatically the same thing. Physical office, discovery city from data collection and stated service area are separate fields. A nearby office does not prove that a company serves your address.

How service filters work

Work, material and property type must match inside one documented service offer. For example, asphalt repair on one page and metal installation on another do not create a “metal repair” result. Ambiguous multi-work or multi-material paragraphs are skipped. Each canonical offer is counted once and linked to multiple evidence observations separately. Blog mentions alone do not create offers. Positive current observations determine inclusion; unknown does not mean false.

Sorting, pagination and comparison

Default catalog order uses rating, review count and deterministic tie-breakers. Best Match after filtering prioritizes a stated service-area match and matching offer before reputation. Most Reviewed sorts by review count; By Rating requires at least 10 reviews. No paid placement is mixed into these rules.

The first catalog page is indexable. Later static pages use self-canonicals and noindex,follow; filtered query views and the comparison dialog do not create indexable URLs.

Replacement calculator · model 1.0

The calculator multiplies roof area by a published national material benchmark, then applies disclosed editorial factors: steep pitch ×1.15, two or more stories ×1.05, moderate complexity ×1.08 and complex layout ×1.18. Georgia location does not change the rate in version 1.0.

Base installation is modeled with one standard layer of removal. An additional layer, estimated decking and optional gutters are separate line items. Footprint mode converts to roof area using ×1.08 for low pitch, ×1.15 for standard and ×1.35 for steep; direct roof measurement is preferred.

RoofingCalculator.com, observed November 15, 2026, supplies national material, removal, decking and gutter benchmarks. Complexity multipliers and the Georgia-neutral model are editorial assumptions, not surveyed contractor quotes. Results are rounded planning ranges, not offers or insurance estimates.

Corrections and limits

Source errors do not erase earlier facts or close a company. Failed expansion requests remain marked as errors, not negative evidence. Fifty-seven review issues remain open, including domain and geography checks. Send the profile URL and supporting source through corrections.